libra/docs/stories/story-3.5-admin-booking-review-approval.md

# Story 3.5: Admin Booking Review & Approval

## Epic Reference
**Epic 3:** Booking & Consultation System

## User Story
As an **admin**,
I want **to review, categorize, and approve or reject booking requests**,
So that **I can manage my consultation schedule and set appropriate consultation types**.

## Story Context

### Existing System Integration
- **Integrates with:** consultations table, notifications, .ics generation
- **Technology:** Livewire Volt, Flux UI
- **Follows pattern:** Admin action workflow
- **Touch points:** Client notifications, calendar file

## Acceptance Criteria

### Pending Bookings List
- [x] View all pending booking requests
- [x] Display: client name, requested date/time, submission date
- [x] Show problem summary preview
- [x] Click to view full details
- [x] Sort by date (oldest first default)
- [x] Filter by date range

### Booking Details View
- [x] Full client information
- [x] Complete problem summary
- [x] Client consultation history
- [x] Requested date and time

### Approval Workflow
- [x] Set consultation type:
  - Free consultation
  - Paid consultation
- [x] If paid: set payment amount
- [x] If paid: add payment instructions (optional)
- [x] Approve button with confirmation
- [x] On approval:
  - Status changes to 'approved'
  - Client notified via email
  - .ics calendar file attached to email
  - Payment instructions included if paid

### Rejection Workflow
- [x] Optional rejection reason field
- [x] Reject button with confirmation
- [x] On rejection:
  - Status changes to 'rejected'
  - Client notified via email with reason

### Quick Actions
- [x] Quick approve (free) button on list
- [x] Quick reject button on list
- [ ] Bulk actions (optional)

### Quality Requirements
- [x] Audit log for all decisions
- [x] Bilingual notifications
- [x] Tests for approval/rejection flow

## Technical Notes

### Consultation Status Flow
```
pending -> approved (admin approves)
pending -> rejected (admin rejects)
approved -> completed (after consultation)
approved -> no_show (client didn't attend)
approved -> cancelled (admin cancels)
```

### Volt Component for Review
```php
<?php

use App\Models\Consultation;
use App\Notifications\BookingApproved;
use App\Notifications\BookingRejected;
use App\Services\CalendarService;
use Livewire\Volt\Component;

new class extends Component {
    public Consultation $consultation;

    public string $consultationType = 'free';
    public ?float $paymentAmount = null;
    public string $paymentInstructions = '';
    public string $rejectionReason = '';

    public bool $showApproveModal = false;
    public bool $showRejectModal = false;

    public function mount(Consultation $consultation): void
    {
        $this->consultation = $consultation;
    }

    public function approve(): void
    {
        $this->validate([
            'consultationType' => ['required', 'in:free,paid'],
            'paymentAmount' => ['required_if:consultationType,paid', 'nullable', 'numeric', 'min:0'],
            'paymentInstructions' => ['nullable', 'string', 'max:1000'],
        ]);

        $this->consultation->update([
            'status' => 'approved',
            'type' => $this->consultationType,
            'payment_amount' => $this->consultationType === 'paid' ? $this->paymentAmount : null,
            'payment_status' => $this->consultationType === 'paid' ? 'pending' : 'not_applicable',
        ]);

        // Generate calendar file
        $calendarService = app(CalendarService::class);
        $icsContent = $calendarService->generateIcs($this->consultation);

        // Send notification with .ics attachment
        $this->consultation->user->notify(
            new BookingApproved(
                $this->consultation,
                $icsContent,
                $this->paymentInstructions
            )
        );

        // Log action
        AdminLog::create([
            'admin_id' => auth()->id(),
            'action_type' => 'approve',
            'target_type' => 'consultation',
            'target_id' => $this->consultation->id,
            'old_values' => ['status' => 'pending'],
            'new_values' => [
                'status' => 'approved',
                'type' => $this->consultationType,
                'payment_amount' => $this->paymentAmount,
            ],
            'ip_address' => request()->ip(),
        ]);

        session()->flash('success', __('messages.booking_approved'));
        $this->redirect(route('admin.bookings.pending'));
    }

    public function reject(): void
    {
        $this->validate([
            'rejectionReason' => ['nullable', 'string', 'max:1000'],
        ]);

        $this->consultation->update([
            'status' => 'rejected',
        ]);

        // Send rejection notification
        $this->consultation->user->notify(
            new BookingRejected($this->consultation, $this->rejectionReason)
        );

        // Log action
        AdminLog::create([
            'admin_id' => auth()->id(),
            'action_type' => 'reject',
            'target_type' => 'consultation',
            'target_id' => $this->consultation->id,
            'old_values' => ['status' => 'pending'],
            'new_values' => [
                'status' => 'rejected',
                'reason' => $this->rejectionReason,
            ],
            'ip_address' => request()->ip(),
        ]);

        session()->flash('success', __('messages.booking_rejected'));
        $this->redirect(route('admin.bookings.pending'));
    }
};
```

### Blade Template for Approval Modal
```blade
<flux:modal wire:model="showApproveModal">
    <flux:heading>{{ __('admin.approve_booking') }}</flux:heading>

    <div class="space-y-4 mt-4">
        <!-- Client Info -->
        <div class="bg-cream p-3 rounded-lg">
            <p><strong>{{ __('admin.client') }}:</strong> {{ $consultation->user->name }}</p>
            <p><strong>{{ __('admin.date') }}:</strong>
                {{ $consultation->scheduled_date->translatedFormat('l, d M Y') }}</p>
            <p><strong>{{ __('admin.time') }}:</strong>
                {{ Carbon::parse($consultation->scheduled_time)->format('g:i A') }}</p>
        </div>

        <!-- Consultation Type -->
        <flux:field>
            <flux:label>{{ __('admin.consultation_type') }}</flux:label>
            <flux:radio.group wire:model.live="consultationType">
                <flux:radio value="free" label="{{ __('admin.free_consultation') }}" />
                <flux:radio value="paid" label="{{ __('admin.paid_consultation') }}" />
            </flux:radio.group>
        </flux:field>

        <!-- Payment Amount (if paid) -->
        @if($consultationType === 'paid')
            <flux:field>
                <flux:label>{{ __('admin.payment_amount') }} *</flux:label>
                <flux:input
                    type="number"
                    wire:model="paymentAmount"
                    step="0.01"
                    min="0"
                />
                <flux:error name="paymentAmount" />
            </flux:field>

            <flux:field>
                <flux:label>{{ __('admin.payment_instructions') }}</flux:label>
                <flux:textarea
                    wire:model="paymentInstructions"
                    rows="3"
                    placeholder="{{ __('admin.payment_instructions_placeholder') }}"
                />
            </flux:field>
        @endif
    </div>

    <div class="flex gap-3 mt-6">
        <flux:button wire:click="$set('showApproveModal', false)">
            {{ __('common.cancel') }}
        </flux:button>
        <flux:button variant="primary" wire:click="approve">
            {{ __('admin.approve') }}
        </flux:button>
    </div>
</flux:modal>
```

### Pending Bookings List Component
```php
<?php

use App\Models\Consultation;
use Livewire\Volt\Component;
use Livewire\WithPagination;

new class extends Component {
    use WithPagination;

    public string $dateFrom = '';
    public string $dateTo = '';

    public function with(): array
    {
        return [
            'bookings' => Consultation::where('status', 'pending')
                ->when($this->dateFrom, fn($q) => $q->where('scheduled_date', '>=', $this->dateFrom))
                ->when($this->dateTo, fn($q) => $q->where('scheduled_date', '<=', $this->dateTo))
                ->with('user')
                ->orderBy('scheduled_date')
                ->orderBy('scheduled_time')
                ->paginate(15),
        ];
    }

    public function quickApprove(int $id): void
    {
        $consultation = Consultation::findOrFail($id);
        $consultation->update([
            'status' => 'approved',
            'type' => 'free',
            'payment_status' => 'not_applicable',
        ]);

        // Generate and send notification with .ics
        // ...

        session()->flash('success', __('messages.booking_approved'));
    }

    public function quickReject(int $id): void
    {
        $consultation = Consultation::findOrFail($id);
        $consultation->update(['status' => 'rejected']);

        // Send rejection notification
        // ...

        session()->flash('success', __('messages.booking_rejected'));
    }
};
```

### Notification Classes
Create these notification classes in `app/Notifications/`:

```php
// app/Notifications/BookingApproved.php
namespace App\Notifications;

use App\Models\Consultation;
use Illuminate\Bus\Queueable;
use Illuminate\Contracts\Queue\ShouldQueue;
use Illuminate\Notifications\Messages\MailMessage;
use Illuminate\Notifications\Notification;

class BookingApproved extends Notification implements ShouldQueue
{
    use Queueable;

    public function __construct(
        public Consultation $consultation,
        public string $icsContent,
        public ?string $paymentInstructions = null
    ) {}

    public function via(object $notifiable): array
    {
        return ['mail'];
    }

    public function toMail(object $notifiable): MailMessage
    {
        $locale = $notifiable->preferred_language ?? 'ar';

        return (new MailMessage)
            ->subject($this->getSubject($locale))
            ->markdown('emails.booking.approved', [
                'consultation' => $this->consultation,
                'paymentInstructions' => $this->paymentInstructions,
                'locale' => $locale,
            ])
            ->attachData(
                $this->icsContent,
                'consultation.ics',
                ['mime' => 'text/calendar']
            );
    }

    private function getSubject(string $locale): string
    {
        return $locale === 'ar'
            ? 'تمت الموافقة على حجز استشارتك'
            : 'Your Consultation Booking Approved';
    }
}
```

```php
// app/Notifications/BookingRejected.php
namespace App\Notifications;

use App\Models\Consultation;
use Illuminate\Bus\Queueable;
use Illuminate\Contracts\Queue\ShouldQueue;
use Illuminate\Notifications\Messages\MailMessage;
use Illuminate\Notifications\Notification;

class BookingRejected extends Notification implements ShouldQueue
{
    use Queueable;

    public function __construct(
        public Consultation $consultation,
        public ?string $rejectionReason = null
    ) {}

    public function via(object $notifiable): array
    {
        return ['mail'];
    }

    public function toMail(object $notifiable): MailMessage
    {
        $locale = $notifiable->preferred_language ?? 'ar';

        return (new MailMessage)
            ->subject($this->getSubject($locale))
            ->markdown('emails.booking.rejected', [
                'consultation' => $this->consultation,
                'rejectionReason' => $this->rejectionReason,
                'locale' => $locale,
            ]);
    }

    private function getSubject(string $locale): string
    {
        return $locale === 'ar'
            ? 'بخصوص طلب الاستشارة الخاص بك'
            : 'Regarding Your Consultation Request';
    }
}
```

### Error Handling
```php
// In the approve() method, wrap calendar generation with error handling
public function approve(): void
{
    // ... validation ...

    try {
        $calendarService = app(CalendarService::class);
        $icsContent = $calendarService->generateIcs($this->consultation);
    } catch (\Exception $e) {
        // Log error but don't block approval
        Log::error('Failed to generate calendar file', [
            'consultation_id' => $this->consultation->id,
            'error' => $e->getMessage(),
        ]);
        $icsContent = null;
    }

    // Update consultation status regardless
    $this->consultation->update([
        'status' => 'approved',
        'type' => $this->consultationType,
        'payment_amount' => $this->consultationType === 'paid' ? $this->paymentAmount : null,
        'payment_status' => $this->consultationType === 'paid' ? 'pending' : 'not_applicable',
    ]);

    // Send notification (with or without .ics)
    $this->consultation->user->notify(
        new BookingApproved(
            $this->consultation,
            $icsContent ?? '',
            $this->paymentInstructions
        )
    );

    // ... audit log and redirect ...
}
```

### Edge Cases
- **Already approved booking:** The approve/reject buttons should only appear for `status = 'pending'`. Add guard clause:
  ```php
  if ($this->consultation->status !== 'pending') {
      session()->flash('error', __('messages.booking_already_processed'));
      return;
  }
  ```
- **Concurrent approval:** Use database transaction with locking to prevent race conditions
- **Missing user:** Check `$this->consultation->user` exists before sending notification

### Testing Examples

```php
use App\Models\Consultation;
use App\Models\User;
use App\Notifications\BookingApproved;
use App\Notifications\BookingRejected;
use App\Services\CalendarService;
use Illuminate\Support\Facades\Notification;
use Livewire\Volt\Volt;

// Test: Admin can view pending bookings list
it('displays pending bookings list for admin', function () {
    $admin = User::factory()->admin()->create();
    $consultations = Consultation::factory()->count(3)->pending()->create();

    Volt::test('admin.bookings.pending-list')
        ->actingAs($admin)
        ->assertSee($consultations->first()->user->name)
        ->assertStatus(200);
});

// Test: Admin can approve booking as free consultation
it('can approve booking as free consultation', function () {
    Notification::fake();

    $admin = User::factory()->admin()->create();
    $consultation = Consultation::factory()->pending()->create();

    Volt::test('admin.bookings.review', ['consultation' => $consultation])
        ->actingAs($admin)
        ->set('consultationType', 'free')
        ->call('approve')
        ->assertHasNoErrors()
        ->assertRedirect(route('admin.bookings.pending'));

    expect($consultation->fresh())
        ->status->toBe('approved')
        ->type->toBe('free')
        ->payment_status->toBe('not_applicable');

    Notification::assertSentTo($consultation->user, BookingApproved::class);
});

// Test: Admin can approve booking as paid consultation with amount
it('can approve booking as paid consultation with amount', function () {
    Notification::fake();

    $admin = User::factory()->admin()->create();
    $consultation = Consultation::factory()->pending()->create();

    Volt::test('admin.bookings.review', ['consultation' => $consultation])
        ->actingAs($admin)
        ->set('consultationType', 'paid')
        ->set('paymentAmount', 150.00)
        ->set('paymentInstructions', 'Bank transfer to account XYZ')
        ->call('approve')
        ->assertHasNoErrors();

    expect($consultation->fresh())
        ->status->toBe('approved')
        ->type->toBe('paid')
        ->payment_amount->toBe(150.00)
        ->payment_status->toBe('pending');
});

// Test: Paid consultation requires payment amount
it('requires payment amount for paid consultation', function () {
    $admin = User::factory()->admin()->create();
    $consultation = Consultation::factory()->pending()->create();

    Volt::test('admin.bookings.review', ['consultation' => $consultation])
        ->actingAs($admin)
        ->set('consultationType', 'paid')
        ->set('paymentAmount', null)
        ->call('approve')
        ->assertHasErrors(['paymentAmount']);
});

// Test: Admin can reject booking with reason
it('can reject booking with optional reason', function () {
    Notification::fake();

    $admin = User::factory()->admin()->create();
    $consultation = Consultation::factory()->pending()->create();

    Volt::test('admin.bookings.review', ['consultation' => $consultation])
        ->actingAs($admin)
        ->set('rejectionReason', 'Schedule conflict')
        ->call('reject')
        ->assertHasNoErrors()
        ->assertRedirect(route('admin.bookings.pending'));

    expect($consultation->fresh())->status->toBe('rejected');

    Notification::assertSentTo($consultation->user, BookingRejected::class);
});

// Test: Quick approve from list
it('can quick approve booking from list', function () {
    Notification::fake();

    $admin = User::factory()->admin()->create();
    $consultation = Consultation::factory()->pending()->create();

    Volt::test('admin.bookings.pending-list')
        ->actingAs($admin)
        ->call('quickApprove', $consultation->id)
        ->assertHasNoErrors();

    expect($consultation->fresh())
        ->status->toBe('approved')
        ->type->toBe('free');
});

// Test: Quick reject from list
it('can quick reject booking from list', function () {
    Notification::fake();

    $admin = User::factory()->admin()->create();
    $consultation = Consultation::factory()->pending()->create();

    Volt::test('admin.bookings.pending-list')
        ->actingAs($admin)
        ->call('quickReject', $consultation->id)
        ->assertHasNoErrors();

    expect($consultation->fresh())->status->toBe('rejected');
});

// Test: Audit log entry created on approval
it('creates audit log entry on approval', function () {
    Notification::fake();

    $admin = User::factory()->admin()->create();
    $consultation = Consultation::factory()->pending()->create();

    Volt::test('admin.bookings.review', ['consultation' => $consultation])
        ->actingAs($admin)
        ->set('consultationType', 'free')
        ->call('approve');

    $this->assertDatabaseHas('admin_logs', [
        'admin_id' => $admin->id,
        'action_type' => 'approve',
        'target_type' => 'consultation',
        'target_id' => $consultation->id,
    ]);
});

// Test: Cannot approve already processed booking
it('cannot approve already approved booking', function () {
    $admin = User::factory()->admin()->create();
    $consultation = Consultation::factory()->approved()->create();

    Volt::test('admin.bookings.review', ['consultation' => $consultation])
        ->actingAs($admin)
        ->call('approve')
        ->assertHasErrors();
});

// Test: Filter bookings by date range
it('can filter pending bookings by date range', function () {
    $admin = User::factory()->admin()->create();

    $oldBooking = Consultation::factory()->pending()->create([
        'scheduled_date' => now()->subDays(10),
    ]);
    $newBooking = Consultation::factory()->pending()->create([
        'scheduled_date' => now()->addDays(5),
    ]);

    Volt::test('admin.bookings.pending-list')
        ->actingAs($admin)
        ->set('dateFrom', now()->toDateString())
        ->assertSee($newBooking->user->name)
        ->assertDontSee($oldBooking->user->name);
});

// Test: Bilingual notification (Arabic)
it('sends approval notification in client preferred language', function () {
    Notification::fake();

    $admin = User::factory()->admin()->create();
    $arabicUser = User::factory()->create(['preferred_language' => 'ar']);
    $consultation = Consultation::factory()->pending()->create(['user_id' => $arabicUser->id]);

    Volt::test('admin.bookings.review', ['consultation' => $consultation])
        ->actingAs($admin)
        ->set('consultationType', 'free')
        ->call('approve');

    Notification::assertSentTo($arabicUser, BookingApproved::class, function ($notification) {
        return $notification->consultation->user->preferred_language === 'ar';
    });
});
```

## Definition of Done

- [x] Pending bookings list displays correctly
- [x] Can view booking details
- [x] Can approve as free consultation
- [x] Can approve as paid with amount
- [x] Can reject with optional reason
- [x] Approval sends email with .ics file
- [x] Rejection sends email with reason
- [x] Quick actions work from list
- [x] Audit log entries created
- [x] Bilingual support complete
- [x] Tests for approval/rejection
- [x] Code formatted with Pint

## Dependencies

- **Story 3.4:** `docs/stories/story-3.4-booking-request-submission.md` - Creates pending bookings to review
- **Story 3.6:** `docs/stories/story-3.6-calendar-file-generation.md` - CalendarService for .ics generation
- **Epic 8:** `docs/epics/epic-8-email-notifications.md#story-84-booking-approved-email` - BookingApproved notification
- **Epic 8:** `docs/epics/epic-8-email-notifications.md#story-85-booking-rejected-email` - BookingRejected notification

## Risk Assessment

- **Primary Risk:** Approving wrong booking
- **Mitigation:** Confirmation dialog, clear booking details display
- **Rollback:** Admin can cancel approved booking

## Estimation

**Complexity:** Medium
**Estimated Effort:** 4-5 hours

---

## Dev Agent Record

### Status
Ready for Review

### Agent Model Used
Claude Opus 4.5

### File List

**New Files:**
- `resources/views/livewire/admin/bookings/pending.blade.php` - Pending bookings list component
- `resources/views/livewire/admin/bookings/review.blade.php` - Booking review/approval component
- `app/Services/CalendarService.php` - .ics calendar file generation service
- `app/Notifications/BookingApproved.php` - Booking approval notification
- `app/Notifications/BookingRejected.php` - Booking rejection notification
- `resources/views/emails/booking-approved.blade.php` - Approval email template
- `resources/views/emails/booking-rejected.blade.php` - Rejection email template
- `tests/Feature/Admin/BookingReviewApprovalTest.php` - Test suite for approval/rejection

**Modified Files:**
- `routes/web.php` - Added admin booking routes
- `resources/views/components/layouts/app/sidebar.blade.php` - Added navigation link
- `lang/en/navigation.php` - Added booking navigation translations
- `lang/ar/navigation.php` - Added booking navigation translations (Arabic)
- `lang/en/admin.php` - Added booking management translations
- `lang/ar/admin.php` - Added booking management translations (Arabic)
- `lang/en/emails.php` - Added approval/rejection email translations
- `lang/ar/emails.php` - Added approval/rejection email translations (Arabic)
- `lang/en/common.php` - Added common translations (clear, unknown, currency)
- `lang/ar/common.php` - Added common translations (Arabic)
- `composer.json` - Added spatie/icalendar-generator dependency

### Change Log
- Installed `spatie/icalendar-generator` package for .ics file generation
- Created pending bookings list with filtering by date range
- Created booking review page with full client details and consultation history
- Implemented approval workflow with free/paid consultation types
- Implemented rejection workflow with optional reason
- Added quick approve/reject actions from list view
- Created CalendarService for generating .ics calendar files
- Created BookingApproved notification with .ics attachment
- Created BookingRejected notification
- Added bilingual email templates (Arabic/English)
- Added comprehensive admin and navigation translations
- Added audit logging for all approval/rejection actions
- Created 21 tests covering all workflows

### Completion Notes
- All acceptance criteria completed except "Bulk actions" which was marked as optional
- Full test coverage with 21 passing tests
- All 312 project tests pass (748 assertions)
- Code formatted with Pint

---

## QA Results

### Review Date: 2025-12-26

### Reviewed By: Quinn (Test Architect)

### Code Quality Assessment

**Overall Assessment: HIGH QUALITY**

This implementation demonstrates excellent adherence to Laravel and project conventions. The code is well-structured, follows the Volt class-based component pattern, and implements all critical acceptance criteria. Key strengths include:

1. **Proper Status Guards**: Both components correctly check `status !== ConsultationStatus::Pending` before processing, preventing double-processing of bookings
2. **Error Handling**: Calendar generation failures are caught and logged but don't block the approval flow
3. **User Existence Checks**: Notifications only send if `$consultation->user` exists
4. **Comprehensive Audit Logging**: All actions are logged with old/new values and IP address
5. **Clean Separation of Concerns**: CalendarService handles ICS generation, Notifications handle email delivery

### Refactoring Performed

None required. The code quality is excellent and follows all project patterns.

### Compliance Check

- Coding Standards: ✓ Code formatted with Pint, follows Laravel 12 conventions
- Project Structure: ✓ Volt components in correct location, follows existing patterns
- Testing Strategy: ✓ 21 comprehensive tests covering all workflows
- All ACs Met: ✓ All acceptance criteria implemented (bulk actions marked optional in story)

### Requirements Traceability

| AC | Description | Test Coverage |
|----|-------------|---------------|
| 1 | View all pending booking requests | `pending bookings list displays pending consultations` |
| 2 | Display client name, date/time, submission date | `pending.blade.php` displays all fields |
| 3 | Show problem summary preview | `Str::limit($booking->problem_summary, 150)` |
| 4 | Click to view full details | `review` route and component |
| 5 | Sort by date (oldest first) | `orderBy('booking_date')->orderBy('booking_time')` |
| 6 | Filter by date range | `admin can filter bookings by date range` |
| 7 | Full client information | `review.blade.php` client information section |
| 8 | Complete problem summary | `whitespace-pre-wrap` display in review |
| 9 | Client consultation history | `booking details view shows client consultation history` |
| 10 | Set consultation type (free/paid) | `admin can approve booking as free/paid` |
| 11 | Payment amount for paid | `paid consultation requires payment amount` |
| 12 | Payment instructions | `paymentInstructions` field in modal |
| 13 | Approve with confirmation | `showApproveModal` with confirm |
| 14 | Status changes to approved | Tests verify `status->toBe(ConsultationStatus::Approved)` |
| 15 | Client notified via email | `Notification::assertSentTo` tests |
| 16 | .ics calendar attached | `CalendarService::generateIcs` + `attachData` |
| 17 | Payment instructions in email | Included in `BookingApproved` notification |
| 18 | Rejection reason field | `rejectionReason` input in modal |
| 19 | Reject with confirmation | `showRejectModal` with confirm |
| 20 | Rejection notification | `BookingRejected` notification sent |
| 21 | Quick approve button | `quickApprove` method tested |
| 22 | Quick reject button | `quickReject` method tested |
| 23 | Audit log for decisions | `audit log entry created on approval/rejection` tests |
| 24 | Bilingual notifications | `notification sent in client preferred language` tests |

### Improvements Checklist

- [x] Status guard prevents double-processing (already implemented)
- [x] Error handling for calendar generation (already implemented)
- [x] Null safety for user notifications (already implemented)
- [x] Audit logging with context (already implemented)
- [x] Bilingual support for emails (already implemented)
- [ ] Consider adding database transaction with locking for concurrent approval protection (future enhancement)
- [ ] Bulk actions (marked as optional in story - not implemented)

### Security Review

**Status: PASS**

1. **Authorization**: Routes are protected by `admin` middleware (verified in routes/web.php)
2. **Access Control Tests**: Tests verify guests and clients cannot access admin booking pages
3. **Input Validation**: Proper validation rules for consultation type and payment amount
4. **Audit Trail**: All admin actions logged with admin_id, action, target, and IP address
5. **Status Guards**: Cannot re-process already processed bookings

### Performance Considerations

**Status: PASS**

1. **Eager Loading**: `with('user')` used consistently to prevent N+1 queries
2. **Pagination**: List uses pagination (15 per page)
3. **Limited History**: Consultation history limited to 5 records
4. **Selective Fields**: User relation loads only needed fields: `id,full_name,email,phone,user_type`
5. **Queued Notifications**: Both `BookingApproved` and `BookingRejected` implement `ShouldQueue`

### Files Modified During Review

None - no modifications required.

### Gate Status

Gate: **PASS** → docs/qa/gates/3.5-admin-booking-review-approval.yml

### Recommended Status

✓ **Ready for Done**

The implementation is complete, well-tested, and follows all project conventions. All 21 tests pass with 47 assertions. The code demonstrates excellent quality with proper error handling, security measures, and bilingual support.

**Note to Story Owner**: Consider implementing bulk actions in a future story if the admin frequently needs to process multiple bookings at once.