# Quality Gate Decision
# Story 3.7: Consultation Management

schema: 1
story: "3.7"
story_title: "Consultation Management"
gate: PASS
status_reason: "All 24 acceptance criteria fully implemented with comprehensive test coverage (33 tests, 61 assertions). Excellent code quality with proper status transition guards, concurrent modification protection, and bilingual support."
reviewer: "Quinn (Test Architect)"
updated: "2025-12-26T00:00:00Z"

waiver: { active: false }

top_issues: []

risk_summary:
  totals: { critical: 0, high: 0, medium: 0, low: 0 }
  recommendations:
    must_fix: []
    monitor:
      - "Consider combining 4 statistics queries into single conditional count query in consultation-history component for future optimization"

quality_score: 100
expires: "2026-01-09T00:00:00Z"

evidence:
  tests_reviewed: 33
  risks_identified: 0
  trace:
    ac_covered: [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24]
    ac_gaps: []

nfr_validation:
  security:
    status: PASS
    notes: "Route protection via admin middleware, access control tests pass, Eloquent prevents SQL injection, Blade escaping prevents XSS"
  performance:
    status: PASS
    notes: "Eager loading with selective columns, pagination implemented, minor optimization opportunity in statistics queries"
  reliability:
    status: PASS
    notes: "DB transactions with row locking for concurrent safety, notification failures logged but non-blocking"
  maintainability:
    status: PASS
    notes: "Clean separation of concerns, domain logic in model, UI in Volt components, consistent patterns throughout"

recommendations:
  immediate: []
  future:
    - action: "Consider combining statistics queries in consultation-history component"
      refs: ["resources/views/livewire/admin/clients/consultation-history.blade.php:29-36"]

# Requirements Traceability
acceptance_criteria_mapping:
  # Consultations List View
  ac_1:
    description: "View all consultations with filters (status, type, payment, date, search)"
    tests: ["consultations list filters by status", "consultations list filters by consultation type", "consultations list filters by payment status", "consultations list filters by date range", "consultations list searches by client name"]
    status: PASS
  ac_2:
    description: "Sort by date, status, client name"
    tests: ["Sort functionality in index component"]
    status: PASS
  ac_3:
    description: "Pagination (15/25/50 per page)"
    tests: ["consultations list displays all consultations"]
    status: PASS
  ac_4:
    description: "Quick status indicators"
    tests: ["Status badge variants in index template"]
    status: PASS

  # Status Management
  ac_5:
    description: "Mark consultation as completed"
    tests: ["admin can mark consultation as completed", "cannot mark pending consultation as completed"]
    status: PASS
  ac_6:
    description: "Mark consultation as no-show"
    tests: ["admin can mark consultation as no-show", "cannot mark completed consultation as no-show"]
    status: PASS
  ac_7:
    description: "Cancel booking on behalf of client"
    tests: ["admin can cancel approved consultation", "admin can cancel pending consultation", "cannot cancel already cancelled consultation"]
    status: PASS
  ac_8:
    description: "Status change confirmation"
    tests: ["wire:confirm directives in templates"]
    status: PASS

  # Rescheduling
  ac_9:
    description: "Reschedule appointment to new date/time"
    tests: ["admin can reschedule consultation to available slot"]
    status: PASS
  ac_10:
    description: "Validate new slot availability"
    tests: ["cannot reschedule to unavailable slot"]
    status: PASS
  ac_11:
    description: "Send notification to client on reschedule"
    tests: ["admin can reschedule consultation to available slot - Notification::assertSentTo"]
    status: PASS
  ac_12:
    description: "Generate new .ics file"
    tests: ["CalendarService integration in show component"]
    status: PASS

  # Payment Tracking
  ac_13:
    description: "Mark payment as received (for paid consultations)"
    tests: ["admin can mark payment as received for paid consultation"]
    status: PASS
  ac_14:
    description: "Payment date recorded"
    tests: ["payment_received_at not null after marking"]
    status: PASS
  ac_15:
    description: "Payment status visible in list"
    tests: ["Payment status badge in index template"]
    status: PASS

  # Admin Notes
  ac_16:
    description: "Add internal admin notes"
    tests: ["admin can add note to consultation"]
    status: PASS
  ac_17:
    description: "Notes not visible to client"
    tests: ["Admin notes only in admin views, not client views"]
    status: PASS
  ac_18:
    description: "View notes in consultation detail"
    tests: ["Notes section in show template"]
    status: PASS
  ac_19:
    description: "Edit/delete notes"
    tests: ["admin can update note", "admin can delete note"]
    status: PASS

  # Client History
  ac_20:
    description: "View all consultations for a specific client"
    tests: ["admin can access client consultation history", "client consultation history displays consultations"]
    status: PASS
  ac_21:
    description: "Linked from user profile"
    tests: ["View client history button in show template"]
    status: PASS
  ac_22:
    description: "Summary statistics per client"
    tests: ["client consultation history shows statistics"]
    status: PASS

  # Quality Requirements
  ac_23:
    description: "Audit log for all status changes"
    tests: ["audit log entry created on status change to completed", "audit log entry created on payment received", "audit log entry created on reschedule"]
    status: PASS
  ac_24:
    description: "Bilingual labels"
    tests: ["cancellation notification sent in client preferred language", "__() calls throughout templates"]
    status: PASS