schema: 1
story: "11.2"
story_title: "Public Booking Form with Custom Captcha"
gate: PASS
status_reason: "All 17 acceptance criteria met with comprehensive test coverage (16 tests, 52 assertions). Strong security implementation with race condition handling and spam protection."
reviewer: "Quinn (Test Architect)"
updated: "2026-01-03T00:00:00Z"

waiver: { active: false }

top_issues: []

quality_score: 100

evidence:
  tests_reviewed: 16
  assertions: 52
  risks_identified: 0
  trace:
    ac_covered: [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17]
    ac_gaps: []

nfr_validation:
  security:
    status: PASS
    notes: "Math captcha + IP rate limiting (5/24h) + lockForUpdate() for race conditions + proper input validation"
  performance:
    status: PASS
    notes: "Queued emails, efficient single-insert transactions, no N+1 queries"
  reliability:
    status: PASS
    notes: "Multi-layer validation, graceful error handling, session-based captcha with refresh capability"
  maintainability:
    status: PASS
    notes: "Clean CaptchaService encapsulation, class-based Volt pattern, proper translation usage"

recommendations:
  immediate: []
  future:
    - action: "Consider phone validation regex for stricter format enforcement"
      refs: ["resources/views/livewire/pages/booking.blade.php:76"]
    - action: "Add ARIA labels to captcha for accessibility compliance"
      refs: ["resources/views/livewire/pages/booking.blade.php:269-280"]
    - action: "Consider logging failed booking attempts for security monitoring"
      refs: ["app/Services/CaptchaService.php"]

files_reviewed:
  - app/Services/CaptchaService.php
  - app/Mail/GuestBookingSubmittedMail.php
  - app/Mail/NewBookingAdminEmail.php
  - resources/views/livewire/pages/booking.blade.php
  - resources/views/livewire/pages/booking-success.blade.php
  - resources/views/emails/booking/guest-submitted/en.blade.php
  - resources/views/emails/booking/guest-submitted/ar.blade.php
  - routes/web.php
  - lang/en/booking.php
  - lang/ar/booking.php
  - tests/Feature/Public/GuestBookingTest.php